Poor Long-Term Outcomes for Participants of the Live-in Caregiver Program

Daphne Cheung

The long-standing stereotype of the Filipino nanny is shockingly difficult to dispel. The Made in Canada report catalogues that 95% of participants of Canada’s Live-in Caregiver Program (LCP) are women; and of these the Toronto Immigrant Employment Data Initiative (TIEDI) reports that 90% were born in the Philippines. While over 88% of participants in the LCP successfully gain permanent resident status in Canada, it is troubling to find that opportunities for these women to improve their long-term economic outcomes are systematically kept out of reach. If live-in caregivers expect to achieve a higher standard of living in the long run through the LCP, their aspirations are usually stifled the day they arrive in Canada.

The Live-in Caregiver Program (LCP) is administered under the federal Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP) and is supported by transnational agreements. It is a National Occupation Classification Level C (Low-Skilled) Program that recruits foreign temporary workers to fill the shortage of inexpensive, round-the-clock care for children, persons with disabilities, and the elderly in private homes. The LCP program is the only route that can lead TFWs towards citizenship; live-in caregivers are eligible to apply for permanent resident status after completing 3,900 hours of work for one employer within four years of arriving in Canada.

Temporary Foreign Workers do not enjoy the same rights and freedoms as permanent residents or Canadian citizens, and as a consequence are vulnerable to abuse. The Law Commission of Ontario reports that fear of repatriation can put workers in a vulnerable position when faced against employer abuse, especially because live-in caregivers are banned from working for more than one employer. Working conditions are determined by a patchwork of provincial employment standards that generally do not oblige employers to compensate live-in caregivers for more than minimum wage. In addition, there is no nation-wide institution for proactive enforcement to ensure both employers and live-in caregivers fulfill contractual obligations. Second-class treatment of foreign-born live-in caregivers does not further the goal of nation building, especially since over 88% of live-in caregivers apply and gain for permanent resident status upon completing the work obligation.

The live-in requirement is an obvious violation of mobility rights, and has negative consequences on a live-in caregiver’s opportunity to develop their social and human capital. Although most employment standards stipulate maximum work weeks of 40-48 hours, the reality of being an isolated live-in caregiver is that employer requests can be answered to at any hour. Live-in caregivers do not have the right to access post-secondary education, making any previous skilled training (over 63% of live-in caregivers have a bachelor’s degree at time of arrival) obsolete as time goes on. According to Naomi Alboim, having a supportive social network and opportunities for ensuring human capital is transferrable to Canada are vital factors that determine the long-term economic outcomes of immigrants, meaning live-in caregivers clearly miss out.

High financial costs and minimum wage pay prevent live-in caregivers from being able to support their families to enter Canada, and media reports find that families are often separated for three to seven years.  Even after being reunited with family in Canada, economic outcomes for children still appear grim. Interviews with high school teachers showed that the majority of children of Filipino temporary workers do not perform well academically. The Toronto Immigrant Employment Data Initiative (TIEDI) has reported that the proportion of child dependents arriving under the LCP increased from 37% in 2000 to 50% in 2009, which could indicate that the negative long-term consequences of fractured familial relationships is a growing problem.

Future demand for live-in caregivers and alternative at-home care for the elderly will only grow as the Canadian population ages and dual-income earning families remain the norm. Worker de-skilling will only emphasize the systematic barriers that prevent live-in caregivers from contributing to projected labour shortages in other skilled sectors such as the Canadian healthcare sector.

In Canada, private care outside the home is less convenient than hiring a live-in caregiver under the LCP, and only marginally cheaper. Canadian parents can pay a private daycare $700 to $1000 per month per child. By comparison, depending on the province, the cost of one live-in caregiver under the LCP is $1,300 to $1,800 per month.

Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) intends on expanding the program rapidly. In October 2013, the CIC announced that it will admit 17,500 permanent residents through the LCP in 2014 – almost double the number in 2012. This represents the highest number of LCP admissions in a single year since the program began in 1993, and eliminates the backlog recorded. Remittances contribute to 11% of the Philippines’ GDP.

The Caregivers Action Centre, Workers’ Action Centre, INTERCEDE, and regional legal services across the country such as West Coast Domestic Workers’ Association and Parkdale Community Legal Services advocate fundamental changes to the temporary foreign worker program. They support permanent resident status for live-in caregivers, elimination of employer-specific work permits, equal legal protection and rights, equal access to social and academic programs and resources, and a just appeals process for repatriations. Until these reforms take place these organizations support increased protection for live-in caregivers and proactive enforcement of provincial employment standards regulations.

There is a more fundamental problem that enables the exploitative practices of the LCP: Canadians simply don’t value carework enough. For Canadian-born women to further their own economic ambitions, why do they need to resort to stifling the economic opportunities of a foreign woman? Until we are prepared to address the true costs of providing adequate care for the children, the elderly, and persons with disabilities, the problematic LCP will remain.

Daphne Cheung is a 2015 Master of Public Policy Candidate at the University of Toronto’s School of Public Policy & Governance, and holds an Honours Bachelor of Science in Chemistry. She is excited to pursue a variety of policy interests, including social, education, economic, and environmental policy.


18 Comments Add yours

  1. Terasita says:

    This writer didn’t do her home work because admitting 17. 500 live in caregivers with PR status doesn’t really solve the huge backlog because every day, every month more and more live in caregivers are applying for PR and the backlog will continue to grow with much longer waiting times. It is very sad the we are not taken seriously with this government. We shouldn’t have to wait 5 -7 years to be with our famlies

  2. JoJo says:

    The Immigration Minister has said that the program is unmanageable so if rumours are true the Live in caregiver will soon be gone all together. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDawjwlZICk

  3. Ian says:

    First, $1300-1800 won’t get you much in the current market. Due to the shortage, live-in nannies who use proper methods to locate work can easily obtain $1500-1800 NET which is more like $1800-2300 total cost for employers, or more. Your figure of $1300 would not even cover legal minimum wage for all provinces. In Toronto specifically, you should expect to pay a minimum of $1800 all in for the most basic of duties.

    The primary problem here is that live in caregivers have still not accepted that the protection for them is easily accessible. They are in fact given similar employment protection rights as Canadians contrary to your post. They seem to just be scared to ruffle feathers. I have begged nannies to report employers paying them $500 a month and making them sleep in furnace rooms. I have pleaded to them not to take jobs that they describe to me and I instantly know will be abusive. Nonetheless, they make poor decisions and come back later with a predictable outcome.

    There are employers literally fighting tooth and nail to find good nannies to live-in and they are paying top salaries with luxury accommodations, benefits and fair treatment. Like poster Maria said above, a lot of nannies can be too picky to their detriment. Canadian families don’t just have 1 child for 8 hours work per day. This week I had an applicant refuse a job with an extremely nice couple and high salary after 3 interviews because she refuses to change diapers! I have to wonder what some nannies expect to do in order to earn permanent residence and citizenship on the back of the live in CAREGIVER program here.

    Your are right that there is a section of the employer market that take advantage of the relationship to further their careers. However, this is a minority in the current climate. Young families don’t share the same vision as the previous generation. They want to know they are helping a nanny start a better life here and support that dream.

    One thing the remains absolutely disgusting is the government’s handling of this program. Previous CIC minister Kenney calls the program unmanageable but the truth is that he was just too incompetent to manage it. On top of that is the issue that the Conservative party would much rather keep Filipinas with lower education (ie. caregivers) out of the immigration system and have Canadian mothers stay at home. This has been explicitly stated. There will be no progress to the program until a new government steps in to save this vital source of care for Canadians.

  4. Melvin says:

    The sad part is that thousands of Filipino citizens will no longer have the opportunity to work in Canada if the Live In Caregiver Program gets eliminated by the government. Hope that this is not the case.

  5. jessa says:

    They promise a faster processing of the live in caregiver pr applications and yet up to now there are still a lot of us who failed to receive our PR. processing time was 39 months and our application was already 41 months and not yet done… Each day we are always hoping that one day we can be reunited with our love ones.

  6. If your child already has a favorite sport, it is easy to find a sports camp that offers instruction or an opportunity to play that sport, and if your
    child likes many sports or doesn. A half-day camp could be
    an additional choice, particularly in the summer months.
    The attack on this naval base also reinforces the belief that
    Pakistan at least knew the location of Bin Laden. For something more duarable consider
    card stock or other heavier paper. The internal frame makes it easy to carry even when it.
    Take photos of your family members against the backdrop of a setting or rising sun. This is not a practice allowed, in fact
    strictly against the rules, but what could a few bones
    tossed over the fence harm an animal that crushed bones with its massively
    powerful jaws. All this will help you reduce weight, get in shape and have
    a fulfilling vacation, one whose benefits you can take back home long after you are done with your vacation. They develop self
    esteem and confidence, and knowledge of what
    is required to lead a healthy and a happy lifestyle. Foreign tourists bring overseas currency to our shores,
    so we forgave them their joy, but realised soon after, English was not their best subject.

  7. Good answers in return of this matter with solid arguments and telling everything
    concerning that.

  8. Je vois de suite que vous connaissez superbement bien ce
    que vous avancez

  9. It may sound like a mission, but 20 minutes is not a lot if you think about
    it. It might just be a case of trial and error, if nothing seems to
    work speak to your dermatologist for any advice or try a different acne skin care product.

    It must be protected well if the body is to be kept safe and healthy without any serious problems.

  10. Rub on the paste using a washcloth or just your palms.
    Sunless tanning saves you from the harmful ultraviolet radiation of the sun. And the
    spray gun is not a Wagner as she laughed but a specially designed high tech sprayer just for spray tans.
    You want a natural-looking golden sheen to your skin. Plush interiors and
    added extras can give you the best value for your money and
    you also want to feel glamorous and like you are being treated like a celebrity.
    Open up a bottle of fake tan and have yourself the best appearance.
    Neglecting Exfoliation – Not exfoliating the skin properly before your sunless tanning sessions may also
    result in an orange skin tone. According to Sky News the Debenhams chain in the UK ‘saw fake tan flying off the shelves with sales up 219% compared with the same day
    last year. To get a really even finish on their tan the person is advised to wax
    or use a razor to clean the skin of hair before their tanning application.
    This is due to the fact that lower quality spray tanning solutions can block the nozzle and result in uneven tanning on people’s skin.

  11. As of June 19, 2014 the processing time for permanent residence under the live-in caregiver program is 38 months. However, since 2013 some of the applicants have received their permanent residence in a year or less.

    For applicants submitting on time is an important factor in either getting an open work permit or permanent residence or any type of permit/visa.

    It is not just about seeking facilitation on the part of the immigration so it is important for live-in caregivers to stay up-to-date, act ahead of time, and anticipate further changes.

  12. It is usually at this point that the most junior member of the household suggests that maybe I should
    put more water in the bowl so that the plunger has half a chance of success.

    Most plumbing services are available around the clock; therefore, you can call them at any time of the day or night.
    Do not just ask any plumber to come over and do some immediate repairs.

  13. Wonderful beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your
    web site, how can i subscribe for a blog site? The account aided me a acceptable deal.
    I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear idea

  14. If you really want a little gleam to set off the room,
    consider using satin finish paint for the trim.
    Perhaps each toilet flush is becoming a little slower, or the
    tub isn’t draining after a shower, or an ominous
    noise is emanating from the sink. Due to the high level
    of customization, it is very easy to ruin or severely impair a character in Champions Online.

  15. Orissa is in the process of working with group homes of dysfunctional children. Looking beautiful doesn’t
    have to be hard on your budget or the environment. It becomes difficult to treat these scars and therefore acne must be treated with the help of oral drugs and topical creams
    and lotions.

  16. This post is truly a good one it helps new internet users,
    who are wishing for blogging.

  17. Remarkable things here. I am very happy to see your article.

    Thanks a lot and I am looking forward to contact
    you. Will you please drop me a e-mail?

Leave a Reply to Ian Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s